10 Creative Newsletter Incentives to Grow Your Author Email List
One of the most underutilized marketing tools in your toolkit? Your email list.
Unlike social media, where algorithms decide who sees your posts, your email list is a direct, guaranteed way to reach your readers—the ones most likely to buy your books, leave reviews, and become lifelong fans. But here’s the catch: no one’s signing up just because you say “Get my updates!” (yawn).
Readers need a juicy, can’t-miss reason to hand over their email, and that’s where creative, high-value incentives come in. Forget the boring stuff—this post is packed with unique, irresistible ideas that will have readers excited to join your list and stay engaged for the long haul!
Before we start, check out my FREE newsletter sign-up booster to help grow your list!
10 Creative Newsletter Incentives to Get More Subscribers
1. A “Write Your Own Adventure” Challenge
Give your readers the power to shape part of your next book by letting them name a character, choose a setting, or influence a minor plot twist. Make this an exclusive subscriber event, where they vote through an email poll, ensuring only your most engaged readers get a say. This not only builds excitement around your book but also creates a personal investment for readers who will be eager to see their choices reflected in the final story.
2. A Digital Annotated Chapter
Offer an exclusive annotated version of a chapter from your book, complete with your behind-the-scenes notes, inspirations, and alternate plot ideas. This gives fans an intimate look at your creative process, making them feel like insiders. Example: “See my original notes and thoughts behind the first chapter of [Book Title]!” This is an excellent incentive for craft-conscious readers who love diving deeper into storytelling techniques.
3. Personalized Book Recommendations from You
Readers love discovering new books, so why not create a custom reading guide based on your genre, writing influences, or personal favorites? This could be a “10 Books to Read If You Loved [Your Book Title]” list or a personalized recommendation guide based on a short reader quiz. Not only does this provide valuable content, but it also establishes your credibility as a trusted voice in your genre.
4. An Interactive “Solve the Mystery” or Riddle Challenge
If you write mystery, thriller, or fantasy, send readers an exclusive puzzle, coded message, or riddle that they must solve to unlock a hidden reward—like a sneak peek at your next book or an exclusive scene. Example: “Solve this riddle to access a secret page on my website with a never-before-seen excerpt!” This taps into readers’ curiosity, making them more engaged with your emails and excited to participate.
5. A Printable “Reading Journal” or Book Tracker
Give your subscribers a beautifully designed reading log or book tracker that lets them keep track of their reading habits. Customize it to fit your genre—like a “Magical Realms Reading Log” for fantasy readers or a “Love Story Tracker” for romance fans. This isn’t just a freebie—it’s a useful, evergreen tool that will keep your name in front of your audience every time they use it.
6. A Monthly “Ask Me Anything” (AMA) Session
Build a deeper connection with your audience by hosting an exclusive monthly AMA session just for your subscribers. Readers can submit questions about your books, writing process, or even fun personal topics, and you can respond via a blog post, email Q&A, or a live video session. Readers love personal interaction with authors, and this helps turn casual readers into loyal superfans.
7. A Custom “Book Soundtrack” Playlist
Bring your book to life through music by curating a Spotify or YouTube playlist inspired by your characters, setting, or themes. This could be a “Soundtrack for [Your Book Title]” featuring songs that fueled your writing process or reflect your characters’ emotions. Fans will love experiencing your story in a new way, making them more immersed in your world.
8. “Write With Me” – A Mini Writing Workshop or Prompt Challenge
For authors with a crossover audience of aspiring writers, offering a mini writing challenge can be an engaging way to build your community. Example: “Join my 3-day writing challenge inspired by my novel’s world-building techniques!”This could be a series of emails with prompts, video lessons, or downloadable PDFs that offer interactive value beyond just promoting your books.
9. A Personalized "Reader Horoscope" or Character Match Quiz
Give your subscribers a fun and interactive experience by creating a custom “Reader Horoscope” based on your book’s themes or a “Which Character Are You?” quiz. Example: “Find out which of my characters matches your personality—take the quiz and get a custom description in your inbox!” Use a tool like Typeform or Interact to make it easy to engage, and require an email sign-up to receive the results. This kind of incentive is highly shareable, meaning your current subscribers may even forward it to their friends, helping you grow your list organically!
10. A Fun “Book Club Guide” for Your Novel
Help readers deepen their experience with your book by offering a book club discussion guide filled with thought-provoking questions, behind-the-scenes insights, and bonus content. Example: “Download my exclusive book club guide for [Your Book Title]—discussion questions, fun facts, and secret details you won’t find anywhere else!” This is perfect for fans who love analyzing stories and discussing them in groups.
How to Effectively Deliver Your Newsletter Incentive
A killer newsletter incentive is only valuable if readers actually receive it and stay engaged. The goal isn’t just to get people to sign up—it’s to turn them into long-term, loyal subscribers who open your emails and stay excited about your books. Here’s how to make sure your incentive does its job.
📩 Set Up an Automated Welcome Email
Nothing kills excitement like signing up for an awesome freebie… and then waiting days to receive it. Set up an automated welcome email that delivers your incentive instantly—whether it’s a download link, an exclusive excerpt, or a subscriber-only video. This not only keeps new subscribers engaged right away but also makes a strong first impression, setting the tone for future emails.
📢 Promote It Everywhere
Your incentive only works if people know about it! Promote your newsletter sign-up across multiple touchpoints—add pop-ups or banners on your website, plug it into your social media bios and posts, and even include a call-to-action in the back of your book. Example: “Enjoyed this story? Get a bonus scene by subscribing to my newsletter at [YourWebsite.com]!” The more places you promote it, the more sign-ups you’ll get.
💡 Keep Engaging Subscribers
Your newsletter incentive is just the beginning of your relationship with readers—now you need to keep them engaged. Follow up with exclusive content, sneak peeks, and personalized emails that make your subscribers feel like VIPsrather than just another name on a list. Show them that signing up was worth it, and they’ll keep opening (and loving) your emails.
Let’s Grow Your Author Email List the Smart Way!
Your email list isn’t just another marketing tool—it’s your most valuable direct connection to readers. By offering unique, irresistible incentives, you’ll attract more engaged subscribers, increase email open rates, and turn casual readers into lifelong fans.
Want an author website that makes growing your email list effortless? I design high-converting, reader-focused author websites that help you get more signups and sell more books! Check out my custom website design services or if you're more of a “DIYer”- browse my templates!
Before you go…check out my Squarespace Author Templates !
Visit the Author Website Template Shop: TEMPLATE SHOP
THE ATWOOD - Squarespace Author Website Template
THE HEMINGWAY - Squarespace Author Website Template
THE GILBERT - Squarespace Author Website Template
